Langsung ke konten utama

WikiLeaks and Diplomacy

Secretary Clinton and Canadian Minister of For...Image via Wikipedia
Ambassador Kishan S. Rana writes:
The release of 250,000 diplomatic 'cables' (a lovely, quaint term) by the US diplomatic system has produced some shock-waves and a vast outpouring of comment. Of course, some faces, belonging to those that acted with indiscretion are red; some political figures are hurt that behind their backs, they are seen in unflattering terms - but is that really so unusual; a few that indiscreetly shared with US diplomats information they should not have given out are truly embarrassed - and one senior official heading the German Foreign Minister's office has reportedly resigned; and the media have had a field day with lots of schadenfreude.
US officials have spoken of grave danger to the system of inter-state exchanges; one reads that Secretary of State Hilary Clinton has telephoned a dozen or more high foreign personalities to apologise for the disclosures.
But is diplomacy, as a process of confidential communication between authorised agents of state, with most such exchanges taking place through conversation and information-sharing, really compromised? Hardly.
Countries and their agents need to share information and to collect data, ALL the time. Yes, it is silly, and even pointless, for Hilary Clinton to have asked US diplomats - not the spooks-in-diplomatic-attire that inhabit the embassies of most countries - to collect email IDs, credit card information and passwords of their foreign interlocutors. I find it hard to believe that she might have been so naive to do this, but perhaps someone acted on her behalf in sending out such bizarre instructions.

The 30-year rule on the opening up of archives is not universal. In the US a fair bit of information is now put out much sooner under its freedom of information provisions. In some other countries too, moves are afoot to publish official material much sooner. In the UK, public disclosure of the 'farewell dispatches' of envoys ending their assignments has been an established tradition, especially when the departing ambassador has written with perspicacity, laced with humor. For instance, some years back a British ambassador to Saudi Arabia, with a reputation as a 'friend of the Arab world' unburdened himself with candid, trenchant comment about the Saudis - and I guess it was one of his non-friends that leaked that dispatch. More recently in 2006, when the departing envoy from Italy, Sir Ivor Roberts unburdened himself, targeting his Prime Minister and others, this rocked the boat for a while and even produced an un-amused response from the FCO, banning the entire institution of farewell dispatches.
Diplomacy is one of the older professions. It has survived over millennia, including the waxing and waning of empires and great powers. It will adapt to the threat of instant disclosure of the 'secret' assessments that embassies and their foreign ministries share among themselves. It might even inspire professional diplomatists to improve their syntax and imagery, so that when the stuff leaks out, they are seen as erudite. Because the sad truth is - especially in India - that our cables (called 'CCB telegrams' in Ministry of External Affairs lexicon) are all too boring, filled with I-me narratives. So if I may presume to advise my friends in the Indian Foreign Service, learn to pull up your socks and smile - you may soon be on camera!
This blog post was first published on http://diplomacyrana.blogspot.com.
Enhanced by Zemanta

POPULAR

Museum Tsunami Aceh Persiapkan Inovasi berbasis Teknologi Digital

MUSEUM Tsunami Aceh terus lakukan inovasi untuk menjadi destinasi edukasi kebencanaan yang lebih modern dan menarik. Dengan mengusung konsep digitalisasi, museum akan memberikan pengalaman baru yang lebih interaktif dan imersif bagi para pengunjung. Kepala Dinas Kebudayaan dan Pariwisata Aceh, Almuniza Kamal, menjelaskan bahwa empat ruang utama di museum akan ditata ulang secara signifikan. Ruang-ruang tersebut meliputi lorong tsunami, memorium hall, lobi lantai dua, dan ruang pameran tetap. "Kami ingin menghadirkan pengalaman yang lebih mendalam dan menyentuh bagi pengunjung. Lorong tsunami akan dilengkapi dengan visual 3D pada lantai dan dinding, menciptakan sensasi seolah berada di tengah gelombang tsunami," ujar Almuniza, Rabu, 17 September 2025. Sementara itu, memorium hall yang ikonik akan diperbaharui dengan serangkaian LED berbentuk persegi panjang, menggantikan layar yang sudah ada. Tujuannya adalah untuk menampilkan konten-konten sejarah dan edukasi secara lebih d...

Museum Tsunami Aceh Hadirkan Koleksi UNHCR sebagai Media Pembelajaran Kebencanaan

UPTD Museum Tsunami Aceh akan segera memperkaya koleksinya dengan penambahan barang-barang bersejarah berupa bantuan kemanusiaan yang digunakan pada masa tanggap darurat, rehabilitasi, dan rekonstruksi pasca tsunami 2004. Koleksi ini akan disumbangkan oleh UNHCR Indonesia sebagai wujud dukungan terhadap upaya pelestarian memori kolektif bencana dan pendidikan kebencanaan. Barang-barang yang akan diserahkan antara lain selimut, ember, perlengkapan dapur, dan tikar yang membawa logo UNHCR. Kepala Perwakilan UNHCR untuk Indonesia, Francis Teoh, menegaskan bahwa benda-benda tersebut bukan sekadar artefak, melainkan simbol nyata dari solidaritas global. “Barang-barang ini merupakan saksi bisu dari upaya kemanusiaan dunia yang menyatu dengan gelombang solidaritas untuk Aceh,” ujar Teoh, Sabtu, 27 September 2025. Teoh yang memiliki pengalaman lebih dari 30 tahun di UNHCR dan terlibat langsung dalam tanggap darurat tsunami Aceh, menambahkan bahwa Museum Tsunami Aceh adalah ruang pembelaj...

GenBI Universitas Islam Aceh Sosialisasi CBP Rupiah di MAN 3 Bireuen

GENERASI Baru Indonesia (GenBI) Komisariat Universitas Islam Aceh  melaksanakan sosialisasi Cinta, Bangga, dan Paham (CBP) Rupiah di Madrasah Aliyah Negeri (MAN) 3 Bireuen, Sabtu, 20 September 2025. Kegiatan ini bertujuan untuk menanamkan kesadaran kepada pelajar mengenai pentingnya mencintai dan menggunakan Rupiah sebagai simbol kedaulatan bangsa. Dalam sosialisasi tersebut, para anggota GenBI memaparkan materi seputar sejarah Rupiah, ciri-ciri keaslian uang, serta cara merawat Rupiah agar tetap dalam kondisi layak edar. Selain itu, siswa juga diajak memahami bagaimana Rupiah mencerminkan identitas dan kebanggaan nasional. Kegiatan berlangsung interaktif dan penuh semangat. Siswa MAN 3 Bireuen terlihat sangat antusias, ditandai dengan banyaknya pertanyaan yang diajukan serta keaktifan mereka dalam mengikuti sesi kuis. Suasana semakin meriah ketika beberapa siswa berhasil menjawab pertanyaan dan mendapatkan hadiah menarik. "Kami sangat senang bisa hadir di MAN 3 Bireuen. Antusiasm...